ED WOODWARD is facing the biggest decision of his short but turbulent reign as Manchester United's executive vice-chairman.
Ryan Giggs, Pep Guardiola and Jose Mourinho are in the frame to replace Louis van Gaal |
The Glazer family, United's
American owners, will be relying on Woodward for the answers to the
club's current crisis. And the pressure is on to get the decision right
to halt United's alarming fall from grace as a football force both
domestically and in Europe.
Former banker
Woodward has the Midas touch when it comes to revenue streams but he
needs to show he is on the money when it comes to football decisions.
He appears to have four options.
First, keep faith with the beleaguered Louis Van Gaal, at least until the summer.
Second,
sack the Dutchman and promote Ryan Giggs, gambling that he can turn
round the team's fortunes despite his lack of managerial experience.
Third,
appoint Jose Mourinho, who is ready and available to provide an instant
lift and has the best track record in world football.
Fourth, wait until Pep Guardiola becomes available this summer and try to lure him away from the clutches of neighbours Manchester City and Chelsea.
Here we look in detail at the options...
Manchester United could stick with Van Gaal but he's losing the fans |
Van Gaal
THE
Dutchman is swimming against the tide now. Crowd opinion has turned
against him, former stars have been putting the boot in all season,
current players are rumoured to be in revolt, and even Van Gaal is
sounding less sure of himself.
At the beginning
of the month, senior United sources were indicating they were happy with
the progress being made and even raised the possibility of extending
his contract in 2017.
But three weeks is a long
time in football. And it is difficult to see what progress has made. He
has got only one more point than David Moyes after 17 games - and Moyes
was still in the Champions League and Capital One Cup.
It
is not just the results, it is also the boring style of play that has
placed a huge question mark over Van Gaal. He could turn it round, but
that is looking increasingly unlikely even with another pot of money to
spend in January when obvious targets will not be available.
It
would be dangerous for United to ignore public opinion and alienate
their fans. After all, they need 75,000 turning up every week to fill
Old Trafford.
Clubs (and countries) managed: Ajax, Barcelona (twice), Holland (twice), AZ Alkmaar, Bayern Munich, Manchester United.
Record: Played 861, won 520, drawn 174, lost 167. Win rate: 60 per cent.
Giggs would be a huge gamble given his lack of managerial experience |
Giggs
UNITED could press the button early on their long-term succession plan by sacking Van Gaal and promoting his No 2.
It
would be a popular choice but it would represent a huge gamble because
Giggs' managerial experience amounts to just four games in charge as a
caretaker when the pressure was off following David Moyes dismissal at
the end of the 2013-14 season.
Giggs, 42, was a
player-coach under Moyes and has been learning the management game under
Van Gaal for the last 18 months. He has seen close pal Gary Neville
take the plunge with Valencia and is now itching for his big chance.
And
as a swashbuckling player under Sir Alex Ferguson for two decades when
he made a record 963 appearances for the club, he would certainly take
the shackles off.
If Giggs is overlooked this
time he may have no option but to cut his ties with the only club he has
worked for to gain management experience elsewhere.
Clubs managed: Manchester United.
Record: Played 4, won 2, drawn 1, lost 1. Win rate: 50 per cent.
Mourinho's sudden availability could have been timed perfectly for the hierarchy at Old Trafford |
Mourinho
THE most obvious option and the one the majority of fans want.
Mourinho
is understood to have always coveted the United job and wasted no time
telling the world he is ready to get back on the horse as quickly as
possible following his shock departure from Chelsea.
There
have been reservations about his confrontational personality and
pragmatic playing style, but no one has a better track record in
management and United's players and fans need an immediate lift.
He
is a proven winner in four different countries, and is more than
capable of handling all the pressure and expectations that come with the
United job. Significantly, Sir Alex Ferguson, who is on United's board,
is a friend and admirer.
And it could be argued
that Mourinho will become an even better manager following the
chastening experience of the last few months at Stamford Bridge.
Clubs managed: Benfica, Uniao de Leiria, Porto, Chelsea (twice), Inter Milan, Real Madrid, Chelsea.
Record: Played 765, Won 505, drawn 154, lost 106. Win rate: 66 per cent.
Guardiola announced last week that he will leave Bayern Munich at the end of this season |
Guardiola
THE
problem with this option is that United will have to wait until the
summer when Guardiola's contract runs out at Bayern Munich.
Like
everyone else in football, they expect the Spaniard has already been
lured to the Blue side of Manchester where he is close friends with
chief executive Ferran Soriano and sporting director Txiki Begiristain,
who worked with him when he was a player and reserve team coach at
Barcelona. And Chelsea are preparing to tempt him with a huge offer.
In
the unlikely event that United haven't already sounded out Guardiola or
his representatives, then that conversation needs to be had.
Are
they prepared to be toyed with by Guardiola only for him to turn round
in the summer and say, 'Thanks, but no thanks, I'm off to the Etihad
where there is a far better squad of players available'?
Clubs managed: Barcelona, Bayern Munich.
Record: Played 375, won 275, drawn 61, lost 39.
No comments:
Post a Comment